Dear Andrea Tapper of Fumba Times,
I hope that this message finds you well and will give you and your periodical some insight as to the local efforts around COVID-19 and the lack of representation in your article. I am writing to you regarding the article on page 3 (Edition 04) of your June – August 2020 issue titled “Great Ways to Support Your Island”. The article is misleading and fails to represent what is actually happening on the island surrounding COVID-19 initiatives. As the founder and CEO of WAJAMAMA Wellness Center and a member of the Zanzibari Diaspora, I am deeply upset and disappointed by the erasure of our efforts as well as the tremendous efforts of other locals around COVID-19 transmission prevention in our community.
In your article you highlighted two women, Nicole Kanz and Natalie Denmeade (the latter of whom has been in Australia during the pandemic), as the driving force behind all of the tireless efforts surrounding COVID-19. Amidst the current global health crisis, and in the context of the Black Lives Matter movement, it is important to note that Nicole and Natalie are both Caucasian. It is safe to say that in both expat and local communities on the island, most people are aware that WAJAMAMA, a Zanzibari owned establishment, has been the driving force behind private sector initiatives aimed at limiting COVID-19 transmissions in Zanzibar.
Our COVID-19 prevention initiatives started in January 2020, when we started producing public health videos regarding ways to limit COVID-19 transmission in both English and Swahili. Shortly thereafter, we started our Infection Control and Hand Hygiene workshops for community groups and businesses. This was only the beginning of our efforts to empower our community with the knowledge to protect themselves and their loved ones through our workshops. We also equipped them with hand washing stations, masks, and educational materials. I, alongside many others, have volunteered our time and expertise, including shutting down WAJAMAMA’s services for two months to focus mainly on COVID-19 initiatives. For the past four months, the team has severely limited the time we get to spend with our families because, as a center dedicated to disease prevention and health promotion, we were compelled and obligated to be at the forefront of fighting for our Zanzibar’s wellbeing.
In March, we used a $1,000 donation from a supporter in the U.S.A. to start setting up handwashing stations, and were delighted to then see the “Zanzibar Community Sinks” initiative begin. At the start of this project, WAJAMAMA was able to support this great initiative by making a donation of buckets and soap and continued to support them by providing educational materials. The commencement of this initiative meant we could focus on the next steps. Our priorities then shifted to fundraising for Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) and working with various groups interested in cloth mask making, as there were cases now being reported in East Africa. Eventually this led to WAJAMAMA raising a further $3,000 in donations from the Rotary Club of Zanzibar and supporters in the U.S.A, to supply PPE for healthcare providers on the frontlines of the fight against COVID-19 in Zanzibar.
Together with our partners, we started our Masks4ALLinZanzibar initiative, in which we organized those interested in making masks, to ensure that high-quality masks were going out to the community. In order to do this, WAJAMAMA brought samples to the Ministry of Health to make sure that they met the Ministry of Health’s requirements. We also put together Ministry of Health-approved information and infographics to go out with each mask in order to ensure that masks are used correctly. We made sure to support local efforts by using $10,000 of funding from donors to purchase locally-made cloth masks, which continue to be distributed to the communities in need. Our Masks4ALLinZanzibar partners include: Zanzibar Apparels, Ozti, K&K Masks, Jenga, Doreen Mashika, and Zivansh.
At the end of March, Nicole Kanz reached out to us regarding ways she could help support WAJAMAMA’s efforts. Nicole and I discussed the importance of tackling COVID-19 from all angles (tourism, health care, economics, food security, etc.). From these conversations, and because I was incredibly busy working out in the field, Nicole put together a “WAJAMAMA Task Force” document (later renamed Zanzibar 2020 in April — three months after we started our COVID-19 initiatives). The document was aimed at facilitating COVID-19 initiatives in the various sectors. Nicole and Natalie have done a tremendous job trying to coordinate COVID-19 efforts on the island.
With the Black Lives Matter movement in mind, I am writing to let you know that we, Zanzibaris, demand better. Leaving out the overwhelming efforts of locals in Zanzibar to combat this pandemic, promotes a white savior complex, whether or not that was the intention of your article. You knew about WAJAMAMA’s efforts. I know this because you spent two hours in my office after we met at an Infection Control and Hand Hygiene workshop we did for the staff of Permaculture & Design Company, VolksHouse and Fortitude Total Security, which took place in Fumba on March 16th, 2020. You interviewed me for two hours about WAJAMAMA and our efforts. This meeting happened long before “Zanzibar 2020”. I am therefore baffled that your article failed to represent WAJAMAMA’s efforts as well as the efforts of other locals such as Zanzibar Apparels, who have played a key role in producing masks for the community, and the Zanzibar Tourism and Local Development, who were the pioneers of the wooden hand-made no-touch hand washing system.
As of June 2020, we have set up more than 300 hand washing stations in both Unguja and Pemba, and distributed almost 10,000 cloth masks, 650 liters of soap, and 30 no-touch hand washing units. We also facilitated the delivery of ~$25,000 worth of PPE to health care workers on the frontlines, and provided 15 educational workshops as well as countless educational material to the community. Additionally, we have also produced 8 educational videos in English and Swahili that have been viewed more than 200,000 times. Disregarding and misrepresenting our efforts not only undermines our work, but also our donors’ generosity.
As a journalist, it is your responsibility to make sure that stories that are published in your newspaper are appropriate, accurate, and culturally competent. As someone with a platform to amplify this island’s efforts against this deadly disease, it is essential to consider who you are centering in this work, and why. Highlighting two White women, who have done an amazing job with Zanzibar 2020, while failing to represent WAJAMAMA and other locally driven COVID-19 initiatives is a part of the chronic white savior complex.
As Zanzibaris, we must do better at recognizing change and efforts within our own community before being quick to allow others to take credit for our successes. The number of volunteers, local businesses and donors that we have been able to rally during this time is unbelievable and is promoting real change in safety and awareness of COVID-19. Our efforts are important and are a direct representation of a community-led grass-roots organization.
You simply must do better.
Kind regards,
Nafisa Jiddawi, MS, FNP-C, WHNP-BC, CNM
17 Comments
Ida Hadjivayanis
This is that piece that had to be written. It is baffling how the efforts of Zanzibaris on the ground are erased so as to promote an image that needs to be decolonised. Very timely article. Thank you WAJAMAMA and all local Zanzibaris doing excellent work – we see you!
Nafisa
Ahsante sana dada Ida! We HAVE to stand up for ourselves… otherwise, who will? If we don’t, our narratives will continue to be erased. We demand better!
Zuwena
I read your letter to the editor. I think you are more interested in self advancement and directing overseas cash to yourself than helping the people. Zanzibar people are hardly mentioned in the letter. All you write is about you. Change your step.
kwa heri
Nafisa
Hello Zuwena. Based on your IP address, AND the fact that you refer to us as “Zanzibar people” rather than Zanzibaris, it’s clear that you are writing from Germany. It would be helpful to know what your connection to Zanzibar is for the sake moving forward with this dialogue.
It’s disheartening that you’re assuming that we, at WAJAMAMA, are corrupt, especially since not a single cent from the COVID initiatives went to WAJAMAMA. Have you read the letter in its entirety? I am surprised that this is your take on it. My letter to the editor was about the fact that local efforts were not represented and gave examples of several of the efforts I was referring to. It would be great if you could respond to the content presented in the letter rather than making wild and baseless allegations.
Karibu Zanzibar.
ANDREA TAPPER, editor, THE FUMBA TIMES
THE FUMBA TIMES answers:
Dear Nafisa,
we’d like to give you our full answer to your letter here but just realised that the space only allows a few lines. So let me just say for now that THE FUMBA TIMES does not discriminate against anybody, that we see the great community work you are doing with Wajamama wellness center and have offered you a feature long since. Can we post more?
Nafisa
Hello Andrea,
I appreciate you acknowledging my letter and I am looking forward to reading the rest of your message before responding. Karibu.
Best regards,
Nafisa
ANDREA TAPPER, editor, THE FUMBA TIMES
THE FUMBA TIMES answers:
We would like to post our reply here, but as mentioned, space restrictions make it impossible. Could you kindly enable us to post it here?
ANDREA
Nafisa
Hello Andrea,
I am not sure who “we” is since the letter was addressed to you but nonetheless, you can try now. I am not sure how to increase the space to be honest, but I did make a few changes and so you can give it a try. If it doesn’t work, you are welcome to break up your reply as multiple comments.
Good luck.
Best regards,
Nafisa
ANDREA TAPPER, editor, THE FUMBA TIMES
THE FUMBA TIMES answers – in portions to fit this page:
Dear Nafisa Levy-Jiddawi,
thank you for your thorough comment on the article „Great ways to support your island“ in our current June-August 2020 issue of THE FUMBA TIMES.
Our intention was to highlight the many amazing initiatives that could be seen in Zanzibar during the corona crisis.
ANDREA TAPPER, editor, THE FUMBA TIMES
I understand that the efforts Wajamama wellness center has made and continues to make during this crisis are immense and there is no doubt about this. But as a newspaper we can give only examples of the many brilliant initiatives, namely over 300. That’s why we talked about “many more people in many more initiatives“ in our articles on the subject.
ANDREA TAPPER, editor, THE FUMBA TIMES
However, I must say, we definitely rebuke the link you have drawn publicly in your open letter – very strongly insinuating suggestions of underlying racism. This allegation is not only entirely unsubstantiated but also unfair. Let me tell you a little bit about the spirit of THE FUMBA TIMES.
ANDREA TAPPER, editor, THE FUMBA TIMES
It was founded to put the pride and appreciation we all share for Zanzibar and Tanzania in words and to support a sense of connectedness on the island and all around the world. The inspiration for this came through the project Fumba Town, East Africa’s first eco town, and its investors from 50 nations, of whom the majority are Tanzanian.
ANDREA TAPPER, editor, THE FUMBA TIMES
As far as community reporting is concerned, of course we report about community efforts and the great work of Zanzibari of all creed and colour all the time, this is at the core of our local lifestyle newspaper. That’s why, for example, we covered the superb achievement of the “green basket“ delivery of Dr. Mwatima Juma on a whole page in the current issue. Our readers…
ANDREA TAPPER, editor, THE FUMBA TIMES
Our readers, international as well as local, are eager to hear exactly about such new approaches!
Regarding your work, I personally offered you an entire feature on your wellness center Wajamama and the pioneer commitment you are showing there. We also invited you to write your own contribution in THE FUMBA TIMES on any tangible topic – unfortunately you don’t mention that. And why wouldn’t we?
Nafisa
Hello Andrea,
Thank you so much for your response. I do mention in my letter that you interviewed me in my office for two hours regarding WAJAMAMA and all of our efforts. In fact, I followed up with the an email (sent on March 25th) stating, “it would be an honor to include WAJAMAMA’s story in Fumba Times. Please let me know if you need any additional information”. In this email, which I would be happy to share publicly if needed, I also stated that I’d be happy to collaborate with you not only on your June issue but also future issues. You did also offer me to write pieces on “beauty in times of corona” and “Ramadhan during corona,” but as I suggested in the email, “beauty” is not a subject I am passionate about (or know much about) and there are better people in Zanzibar who would do a much better job than me regarding this topic. I also mentioned that it is also not my place to discuss matters concerning Ramadhan in times of corona. I concluded my email with “we appreciate your team and look forward to future collaborations. Please let me know if you have any questions”. Regarding featuring our story, as a journalist who interviewed me for two whole hours, I assumed that you would be the one to write that story…
All of the above is beside the point. I did not write my “letter to the editor” because I want to be featured on the Fumba Times. I was simply surprised by who that specific article (not your whole entire publication) chose to focus on. As a publication that was “founded to put the pride and appreciation we all share for Zanzibar and Tanzania,” I (as well as many others) would expect you to represent locally-lead initiatives as much as possible. During the COVID pandemic, locals SHOWED UP. We worked hard. Day and night. Many expats also did amazing work. In my letter to you, I was simply pointing out that choosing to highlight and focus on two Caucasian women, including one who has been in Australia during the pandemic, promotes the chronic white savior complex “whether or not that was the intention of your article”.
“Letter to the editor” is a standard practice for critiquing (and hopefully improving) a publication. Not once in my letter were you OR your larger umbrella company called racist, nor do I suggest that you are. My letter to you regarding the article “Great Ways to Support Your Island,” will hopefully eventually bring self-awareness to you in terms of cultural competency and responsibility for responsible (and proportional) representation.
I tried reaching out to you privately initially regarding this matter (and my goal was to keep that way), but I was not satisfied with the response that I got from you. Since you did not seem interested in admitting that there was an issue with that article, it was important to me to speak up and not let this erasure of the incredible local efforts surrounding COVID go unnoticed.
ANDREA TAPPER, editor, THE FUMBA TIMES
There are many stories not yet told on Covid-19 in Zanzibar, on women, children and so forth – and we’d certainly count on your zest and expertise! Our offer is still standing: We’d be happy to welcome you as a contributor and to cover your Wajamama work. Let’s work together and not against each other.
Kindly,
ANDREA TAPPER & the publishers
Editor, THE FUMBA TIMES
Nafisa
Hello Andrea,
As mentioned multiple times in previous emails, we have always been open to collaborating with you all. Again, my “letter to the editor” was meant to support and give feedback to your fairly new publication. We have no interest in working against you… nor have we ever indicated that.
Thank you.
Nafisa